Our finding

Unproven

The Claim:

Viral Claim: Democrats can now effectively abolish the Electoral College after sweeping the November 3 midterm elections.

Summary:

Misleading: Democrats won five new state trifectas that could lift the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact past 270 electoral votes, but the compact would sideline — not abolish — the Electoral College, and no state has passed the law yet.

Detailed Analysis

WASHINGTON — Within hours of the Democrats' sweep of Congress on November 3, a new claim began racing across X and Instagram: the party had just won the power to "effectively abolish the Electoral College." The posts pointed to five states Democrats had just taken control of and to a long-standing agreement called the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. The arithmetic in the posts is real. The conclusion is not.

The Claim

The viral posts argue that Democrats swept the state legislatures and governorships in five key states — Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin — and can now pass the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in all five, giving the compact enough electoral votes to take effect and end the Electoral College as it works today. One widely shared version put it bluntly: "Dems now have the power to pass the National Voter Compact to effectively abolish the Electoral College."

What the Midterms Actually Changed

The starting premise checks out. Axios reported on November 4 that Democrats won the governor's office and both legislative chambers in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin and Nevada. Those five states hold 61 electoral votes between them: Pennsylvania 19, Michigan 15, Arizona 11, Wisconsin 10 and Nevada 6. The compact, an agreement among states to award their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote, has been enacted by 18 states and Washington, D.C., representing 222 electoral votes — Virginia became the latest to sign on in April 2026, according to USA Today. Add 61 to 222 and the total reaches 283, comfortably above the 270 electoral votes the compact needs to take effect. That is the grain of truth at the heart of the viral claim, and it is why the midterm results have set off a genuine debate about the 2028 election.

Why "Abolish" Is the Wrong Word

The compact would not abolish the Electoral College. The college is written into the Constitution, and removing it would require a constitutional amendment — a proposal by two-thirds of both chambers of Congress and ratification by three-quarters of the states. As USA Today put it in its November 6 report, the compact "would not eliminate the Electoral College — that would require a Constitutional amendment." What the compact would do, if it ever took effect, is sideline the college in practice: participating states would send their electors to the national popular-vote winner, even if that candidate lost inside their own state. The institution would remain on the books, bound to a different result.

Nothing Has Been Passed Yet

Winning a legislature is not the same as passing a law, and no state has joined the compact since the midterms. It is far from clear the new Democratic majorities will make it a priority. Michigan held a Democratic trifecta from 2023 to 2024 and still failed to enact the compact. Nevada's then-Democratic governor, Steve Sisolak, vetoed a bill to join in 2019, warning it could diminish his state's influence in national elections. Battleground states such as Pennsylvania may be reluctant for the same reason, according to Ohio State law professor Edward Foley, because joining could reduce the attention their voters command in a presidential campaign. And even if all five states did pass it, the compact would face legal challenges, including whether it needs congressional approval under the Constitution's Compact Clause — Notre Dame election law professor Derek Muller argues that it does, a fight that would have to survive the Senate's 60-vote filibuster and, most likely, a presidential veto. Under the compact's own terms, it would also need to reach 270 electoral votes by July 20, 2028 to govern that year's election.

Our Finding

The claim is misleading. The five new Democratic trifectas and the 222-to-283 electoral-vote maths are real, and the compact is now within reach in a way it has never been. But "abolish" misstates what the compact does, no state has passed the law, and the path from here to a popular-vote presidency runs through five separate legislatures, reluctant battleground states and a likely Supreme Court fight. Like other viral midterm claims — including the Michigan tabulator story — this one takes a real result and stretches it into a conclusion the facts do not yet support.

Sources

Axios reporting, November 4, 2026; USA Today, November 6, 2026; National Conference of State Legislatures compact records; National Popular Vote organisation figures; Pew Research Center 2024 survey on popular-vote preference; statements by Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller and Ohio State law professor Edward Foley.

Published: November 6th, 2026

Author: Alexander Vance